Federal Way, Tacoma, Seattle, Black Diamond, Puyallup and Surrounding Areas

About Us

Haymaker Insurance Agency

We started our agency with the goal to help people and protect the things they love.
With seven years’ experience in insurance, Tim thought there had to be a better way to make personal insurance, like car insurance & home insurance less complicated. His answer: reintroduce the family owned independent agency back into the community. 

Proudly based in Federal Way, we serve our community and gratefully enjoy having clients throughout the Puget Sound area. 

Tim Hay, Agent / Owner

I grew up all over the world following my Dad’s Air Force career. It’s wasn’t easy moving all the time, but it introduced me Washington, a place I would later call home.  

After serving in the Navy, I returned to Tacoma to start a career in technology sales. I enjoyed several years working for some great companies but my biggest win, meeting my wife along the way.

I became an insurance agent in 2011 and immediately enjoyed helping others meet their needs with coverage & value. Later, we started our business known as Haymaker Insurance.

Today, my wife and I raise our family in Federal Way where we’ve lived for 12 years. We enjoy helping with youth sports, schools and participating in our growing community. 

Community & Around Town

Tim is on his fourth year as volunteer & coach at Federal Way National Little League. He also participates on the League’s Board of Directors. Tim participated in Federal Way’s Citizen’s Police Academy, a two-way educational process creating understanding and communication on citizen issues and police decisions. As a Watch D.O.G.S. Dads of Great Students volunteer Tim helps reinforce the value of education in children.