Federal Way, Tacoma, Seattle, Black Diamond, Puyallup and Surrounding Areas

What you're looking for may
be right where you are now.

Personal insurance options from your local independent agent. Service, value and worry-free solutions. 


Welcome to Haymaker Insurance

We know insurance isn’t fun for you. That’s why we strive to meet your needs as easily as possible. You will always get a friendly advisor, commitment to value and our focus on you.

We are independent so we can help you cover the things you love. By listening we learn what’s important to you and bring options that best fit your needs.

We look forward to talking to you. Give us a call today to see what we can do for you.  253-220-5430.

Request a Quote
What We’re All About

Located in Federal Way, our family insurance agency serves all of Washington.

Since the day we opened our doors our goal has been to provide you with worry-free ownership for the things you love. 

Get affordable options, value and the peace of mind you deserve when we work for you.

Thank you for visiting us. – Tim Hay   

More About Us

Just have a question?
Give us a call 253-220-5430.

Request a Quote: 253-220-5430


Haymaker Insurance proud sponsor of Federal Way National Little League

Federal Way Little League Receives $50,000

Pictured above: Pete von Reichbauer, Sally Bigby, Kirk Westrick, Amy Westrick and Tim Hay with Zackery Heckinger in front. Photo Credit: Olivia Sullivan. Federal Way Little League Receives $50,000 King[…]

Read more
Black Diamond's Ten Trails

Black Diamond’s Ten Trails Hometown Social

Black Diamond’s Ten Trails is a new neighborhood community. Ten Trails describes themselves as “Your new hometown”. “The perfect blend of urban style and rural simplicity. Featuring modern, amenity-filled homes,[…]

Read more
washington earthquake quote

How many of us have earthquake coverage in Washington?

In Washington state what percent of homeowners have Washington earthquake coverage? According to the Washington State Insurance Commissioner only 11% of Homeowners have Washington earthquake insurance. Washington residents know we’re[…]

Read more

Looking for an Insurance Agent?  Call Us: 253-220-5430.

Contact Us